[source: Islam The Straight Path, p. CALIPH UMAR INTRODUCED THE ELECTION COMMITTEE, TO VOTE ON NEXT CALIPH He also introduced a new method for the selection of his successor. On his deathbed, Umar appointed an "election committee" to select the next caliph. After due consultation, the council of electors chose Uthman ibn Affan from the Umayyad clan, a leading Meccan family. This was accompanied by the traditional sign of allegiance, the clasping of hands. Thus, based on the practice of the first three caliphs, a pattern was established for selecting the caliph from the Quraysh tribe through a process characterized by consultation and an oath of allegiance. [source: Islam The Straight Path, p. 36] DANTE PLACED PROPHET MUHAMMAD INTO THE LOWEST LEVEL OF HELL This attitude was preserved and perpetuated in literature such as the Divine Comedy, where Dante consigned Muhammad to the lowest level of hell. [source: Islam The Straight Path, p. 58] WHEN JERUSALEM WAS TAKEN BY MUSLIMS IN 638, EXISTING CHURCHES WERE SPARED, JEWS WERE INVITED TO RETURN AFTER CENTURIES OF EXILE Jerusalem was a sacred city for all three Abrahamic faiths. When the Arab armies took Jerusalem in 638, they occupied a center whose shrines had made it a major pilgrimage site in Christendom. Churches and the Christian population were left unmolested. Jews, long banned from living there by Christian rulers, were permitted to return, live, and worship in the city of Solomon and David. Muslims proceeded to build a shrine, the Dome of the Rock, and a mosque, the al-Aqsa, near the area formerly occupied by Herod's Temple and close by the Wailing Wall, the last remnant of Solomon's temple. [source: Islam The Straight Path, p. 58] SCHOLAR: GOD MAY HAVE WANTED CRUSADES, BUT NO EVIDENCE THE JERUSALEM CHRISTIANS WERE SEEKING RESCUE WHATSOEVER (!) This was ironic because, as one scholar has observed, "God may indeed have wished it, but there is certainly no evidence that the Christians of Jerusalem did, or that anything extraordinary was occurring to pilgrims there to prompt such a response at that moment in history." [source: Islam The Straight Path, p. 58] CRUSADERS KILLED EVERY LAST MUSLIM IN JERUSALEM, MASSACRING MEN, WOMEN, AND CHILDREN In 1099, the Crusades stormed Jerusalem and established Christian sovereignty over the Hold Land. They left no Muslim survivors, women and children were massacred. The Noble Sanctuary, the Haram al-Sharif, was descecrated as the Dome of the Rock was converted into a church and the al-Aqsa mosque, renamed the Temple of Solomon, became a residence for the king. [source: Islam The Straight Path, p. 59] SALADIN RESCUED JERUSALEM FROM CHRISTIANS IN 1187, CHURCHES AND SHRINES INTACT In 1187, Salah al-Din (Saladin), having reestablished Abbasid rule over Fatimid Egypt, led his army in a fierce battle and recaptured Jerusalem. The Muslim army was as magnanimous in victory as it had been tenacious in battle. Civilians were spared; churches and shrines were generally left untouched. [source: Islam The Straight Path, p. 59] SALADIN WAS COMPASSIONATE TOWARDS NONCOMBATANTS The chivalrous Saladin was faithful to his word and compassionate toward noncombatants. [source: Islam The Straight Path, p. 59] RICHARD LIONHEART MASSACRED CIVILIANS WHO HAD ALREADY SURRENDERED Richard accepted the surrender of Acre and then proceeded to massacre all its inhabitants, including women and children, despite promises to the contrary. [source: Islam The Straight Path, p. 59] IBN TAYMIYYAH REJECTED IJTIHAD, OR CLOSING OF THE LEGAL GATE OF SHARIA LAW While individual scholars like Ibn Taymiyya (d. 1328) and al-Suyuti (d. 1505) demurred, the majority position resulted in traditional belief prohibiting substantive legal development. This is commonly referred to as the closing of the gate or door of ijtihad. [source: Islam The Straight Path, p. 84] WALI ALLAH ECHOED IBN TAYMIYYAH, THAT IJTIHAD WAS UNREASONABLE Wali Allah followed Ibn Taymiyyah in calling for the opening of the gates of ijtihad, since the rulings of the old jurists were open to correction in light of the Qur'n and the Sunna. He maintained that the nature of interpretation itself was susceptible to error because of human limitations or because new evidence might arise. [source: Islam The Straight Path, p. 123]